NewsCase StudiesEvents

Bogus Outsourcing In Japan

Also in the news...

Get proof of origin for your goods

If you’re using a preference from a preference agreement or the Generalised Scheme of Preferences, you will need to prove the origin of your goods.

Claiming preferential rates of duty between the UK and EU

How to claim preferential rates of duty on goods covered in the UK's deal with the EU and how to declare goods imported into the UK on your import declaration.

A Step By Step Guide To Forex Trading

Forex Market is also known as Foreign Exchange Market or Currency Trading Market.

Obtaining A Business License In Italy: The Ultimate Guide

Obtaining a business license in Italy: what you need to know

New immigration system: what you need to know

The UK has introduced a points-based immigration system.

Bogus Outsourcing In Japan

Back to News

When a company cannot handle a piece of work, it may outsource this to an individual on a “gyōmu itaku” or outsourcing contract.

Why abuse outsourcing contracts?

It’s about profiting from reduced labour force costs. Contractors are not legally “Employees” and therefore employers can avoid their obligations under the Labour Standards and other laws.

An Employee or a Contractor?

The difference between the Employees and Contractors starts with Article 9 of the Labour Standards Act. An “Employee” is deemed to be in a “subordinate” position. Judgments about whether or not a worker has Employee status are based on the answers to several questions:

· To what degree does the enterprise have authority to give directions to the individual in completing the work?

  • To what degree is the individual bound to time slots and locations?
  • Does the individual have the right to accept or refuse each task?
  • Can the individual freely arrange for another person to fill in for the work?
  • Does the individual own the materials or tools used in carrying out the work?

Someone who comes to the office during set times, works under the authority of their bosses at a designate place and without the right to refuse tasks is an Employee. In return for accepting these working restrictions, there are limitations on Employee’s’ working hours, higher pay for overtime and paid holidays. If they get injured or sick at work, they are eligible to receive workers’ compensation. If they lose their job, they get unemployment benefits.

Someone who can choose the time and place of their work and even whether to complete the task is not in a subordinate position and is not and Employee. Thus labour laws (except the Trade Union Law) do not apply to them. Such Contractors have no right to unemployment insurance, paid holidays or workers’ compensation.

Court contests over Employee status have been fought by truck drivers, singers, TV license fee collectors, journalists, hostess bar staff, monks, sumo wrestlers and many more. Winning or losing makes such a difference from a legal point of view that it is not surprising that many conflicts arise.

Rampant bogus outsourcing (giso ukeoi)

The best known example is Japan’s largest beef and rice shop operator, Sukiya. It has about 2,000 restaurants providing meals 24 hours a day. Until recently its workers received no overtime pay regardless of how many hours they worked because the company maintained that it had a private Contractor relationship with them. The Tokyo Labour Commission ruled in November 2009 that management had committed unfair labour practices by refusing to negotiate with the workers’ Union.

The workers pressed criminal charges against top corporate executives for Labour Standards Act violations (which are criminal offenses that can potentially mean jail time). After an eight-year fight, the company was finally forced (through a settlement with their Labour Union) to recognize that those working at Sukiya branches around the country are Employees.

Realistically it was absurd to suggest that Sukiya staff could work when and where they like without taking orders from superiors.

After all, every Sukiya in Japan sells the same beef and rice, at the same price under the strict control of management. If such conditions allowed them to be Contractors, then pretty well every other worker in Japan would likewise be similarly classified.

Not worth the risk

Bogus outsourcing but is being progressively

distinction between Employees and Contractors


About Jon Sparks

Jon is a Japanese specialist with 2 decades of experience spanning:

  • Board and Management experience in both Japanese and foreign companies
  • Leading or participating in forming over 20 partnerships or acquisitions
  • Representing foreign companies as their senior representative or advisor in Japan

You can contact Jon here

You are not logged in!

Please login or register to ask our experts a question.

Login now or register.